Information: Important Relevant Cases.



Important Relevant Cases


There have been numerous challenges to decisions based on HOC46/2004 guidance. Please click on the links below to download some of the most significant cases.


The Pension Ombudsman :  The Sharp Decision.

The Pension Ombudsman : The Ayre Determination                          

The Turner Decision

The Pollard Decision

The Crocker Case     (Referred to in Turner Case)

McGinley-v-Metropolitan Police  

The Laws Case

The Crudace Case

The Simpson Ca

The Haworth Case

The Walther Case

The Fisher Case


Brief Summary of Relevant High Court Pensions Appeal Cases.